At a glance
Client: a public servant with special status in the public-order structures
Area: administrative litigation, service relationship
Stage: defending a ruling already won, on second appeal
Result: appeal dismissed, judgment final, RON 4,500 in costs paid by the Ministry
The facts
Our client litigated a dispute over his service relationship. In March 2025 the first court ruled in his favour. The Ministry of Interior, joined in the proceedings as guarantor, lodged a second appeal.
When the opponent is a central institution, the case is won twice. Once on the merits, and again on appeal, where the institution has time, resources and in-house lawyers.
What we did
We moved the argument onto procedural ground
On second appeal the facts are not retried. The argument runs solely on the grounds of cassation exhaustively listed by law. We built the defence around that limitation and showed that the institution's criticisms were in truth seeking a reassessment of the facts, which falls outside the scope of the appeal.
We claimed the costs
We asked for the appellant to be ordered to pay costs, a head of claim parties often forget at this stage, even though it carries an additional counsel fee.
The outcome
In December 2025 the appellate court dismissed the Ministry's appeal and ordered it to pay our client RON 4,500 in costs, representing counsel's fee. The judgment is final.
What the file shows
Defending a favourable ruling on appeal is a technical stage, not a formality. The most effective argument is often a procedural one.
And claiming costs shifts the burden of the defence onto the party that started the appeal, which changes the economics of the whole case for the client.
Frequently asked questions
What happens if the institution appeals the judgment I won?
A written defence is filed within the deadline set by the court. The stage is short but decisive, because no new evidence is taken on second appeal and everything turns on the written argument.
What can be argued on second appeal?
Only the grounds of cassation exhaustively listed by law, which concern the lawfulness of the judgment. Criticisms that really seek a reassessment of the facts are rejected as inadmissible.
Can legal costs be recovered from a public institution?
Yes. Public institutions are ordered to pay costs like any other losing party, including counsel's fee for the appeal stage, provided it is expressly claimed.
What service-relationship disputes can be brought?
Disciplinary sanctions, changes to or termination of the service relationship, unpaid salary entitlements, allowances and damages. The deadlines vary with the act challenged, usually 30 days from service.
How long does an appeal in administrative litigation take?
Typically between a few months and a year, depending on the court and its caseload. Here, the appeal was decided in about nine months.







